Friday, December 29, 2006

Right or Wrong?

Mr. A: We must follow the line of mass industrialization…. For that purpose we need to acquire lands…

Mr. B: Stop Nonsense! How can do justice to all those poor farmers mostly depended on the agriculture??

Mr. A: See… If you want to develop the economy industrialization is must

Mr. B: But not for the cause of thousands people fate…

Mr. A: Civilization cannot march back…. So it is obvious choice… and many people will get the job there… their life become more stable

Mr. B: Farmers?? Huh… Why would mfg co. take them??

Mr. A: Company will train them… the other dependant industries will also flourish…that means more jobs…

Mr. B: I cannot accept the fact of building industry in a fertile land… and some primary cereals and vegetables are coming out every year from there

Mr. A: The farmers get compensation for that… and they are getting the best package out there.

Mr. B: All bullshit!! That’s one time compensation can’t compare with what they will earn from the land time after time… and what about other family members who used to do only farming??

Mr. A: The industry will earn 100 times more from a one-acre land compare to farming

Mr. B: That will not serve poor people… it is only for the cream of the society and the capitalist owner.

Mr. A: Capital is flowing all over the world… we need to grab it for our own purpose… and it will definitely by and large serve the poor people also

Mr. B: Bah… then some day one MNC may come and say “we think Maidan is the best place to set up our industry”… and should we grab this for our economic dev??

Mr. A: Now you are talking like a stupid… definitely not… in the midst of a city how come it possible?? Pollution will occur

Mr. B: Hmmm… come to the point… ecology, pollution… How can you discard these facts?? The reality is that you can even sell the maidan for money…. People life’s become commodity now

Mr. A: Stop talking like an old haggard… these are all bogus thoughts... and to prevent pollution you need to plan it properly... if you keep talking about problem rather thinking the alternate way out you will never start a process

Mr. B: Even when I know all these processes are for the betterment of a specific class? Anyway.. Why don’t you choose other infertile lands??

Mr. A: See … Industry needs some favorable situations … I mean transportation, availability of water, power supply access and other dependent industry nearby…

Mr. B: but at the same time this is a fertile land also…

Mr. A: Oh…not again… you know people are getting paid for that… cost of the land for..


the debate must go on….